Generalized Cost-Based Job Scheduling in Very Large Heterogeneous Cluster Systems

We study job assignment in large, heterogeneous resource-sharing clusters of servers with finite buffers. This load balancing problem arises naturally in today's communication and big data systems, such as Amazon Web Services, Network Service Function Chains, and Stream Processing. Arriving jobs are dispatched to a server, following a load balancing policy that optimizes a performance criterion such as job completion time. Our contribution is a randomized Cost-Based Scheduling (CBS) policy in which the job assignment is driven by general cost functions of the server queue lengths. Beyond existing schemes, such as the Join the Shortest Queue (JSQ), the power of d or the SQ(d) and the capacity-weighted JSQ, the notion of CBS yields new application-specific policies such as hybrid locally uniform JSQ. As today's data center clusters have thousands of servers, exact analysis of CBS policies is tedious. In this article, we derive a scaling limit when the number of servers grows large, facilitating a comparison of various CBS policies with respect to their transient as well as steady state behavior. A byproduct of our derivations is the relationship between the queue filling proportions and the server buffer sizes, which cannot be obtained from infinite buffer models. Finally, we provide extensive numerical evaluations and discuss several applications including multi-stage systems.